politics and the “confederate flag”

I find myself in disagreement with much of what politicians from both sides say, often because what they’re concerned with isn’t as much taking care of the American people, but rather taking care of themselves.


Mike Huckabee said something I actually agree with. When questioned by somebody on whether or not South Carolina should stop flying the “Confederate flag” over its capitol, he said – and I quote – ““Everyone’s being baited with this question as if somehow that has anything to do whatsoever with running for president.”

Chuck Todd (who I cannot bring myself to call a journalist) pressed him for a different answer, which Huckabee denied him.

Let’s get something straight. What, exactly, is the “Confederate flag”? If you mean “Confederate flag” in the same way that you mean “Albanian flag,” then it’s the flag of the Confederacy, aka the Confederate States of America. I’m not going to post graphics here, but I’ll describe the actual flag(s) of the CSA for you.

There were three national flags for the CSA.  The first was not unlike the standard USA flag; it had a blue field with a circle of stars (representing the states of the CSA), plus three wide stripes – two red & one white.  The second CSA flag was pure white, and in the top left corner where the blue field/white stars would be on the USA flag, it had the familiar square red background with the blue X and white stars that people associate with the Confederacy.  The third national flag of the CSA was just like that, but with a vertical red stripe flush right – this one was called “the blood-stained banner” to set it apart from the “stainless banner” with the all-white field.

What most people refer to as the “Confederate flag” – the square red flag with the blue X and white stars – is not the CSA national flag and it never was. It was the battle flag of the Army of Northern Virginia.  If you make it rectangular instead of square, that was the battle flag of the Army of Tennessee. Whether it’s square or rectangular, this flag is often mistakenly referred to as the “stars and bars.” The “stars and bars” is actually the FIRST flag of the CSA – the one with the circle of stars and the three stripes (or bars) on it.

Let’s get back to Huckabee. He’s right.  Whether or not South Carolina flies the battle flag of the Army of Northern Virginia over their capitol or not is an issue for the people of South Carolina.  It is NOT an issue for ANYBODY running for president of the ENTIRE nation.  Somebody running for governor of South Carolina? SURE!  President of the country?  HELL NO.

What these so-called journalists like Chuck Todd are trying to do is divide the American people and sow more hatred and divisiveness than we already have.  By drawing attention to this non-national issue, these assholes with media credentials are simply baiting candidates, trying to get them to say something controversial so the media can boost its ratings with salaciousness rather than discussing issues that actually affect real Americans.

Now let’s get back to the issue of whether or not South Carolina should be flying the battle flag of the Army of Northern Virginia.

There’s a state in southeastern Germany called Saxony. In Saxony is the city of Dresden. In the 1930s, Saxony was a hotbed of National Socialist activity, but (like South Carolina) Naziism wasn’t the only philosophy around – it just happened to dominate because of the prevailing attitudes of the times.  You know they flew the Nazi flag (red background, white circle in the center, with a swastika on it) everywhere.  The war ends, the flags come down. Nowadays, there’s a strong neo-Nazi movement in Saxony… but you don’t see Saxony flying the Nazi flag, now do you?  No, because not only is it illegal to do so in Germany, but the reason it’s illegal to do so is because it’s a well-known symbol of hatred and racism.  Nobody in Germany pretends that the Nazi flag isn’t a symbol of institutional racism (“heritage”), and nobody pretends that it isn’t part of their history.

Yes, I am comparing Nazi racists to South Carolina racists.  Racism is racism no matter what your social or political reasons for it are.  The Nazis aimed their racism at Jews, some people in South Carolina aim theirs at blacks.  It’s still racism.  Saying the battle flag of the Army of Northern Virginia is “just a symbol of heritage” ignores the history.  Think what people all over the world would say if Saxony started flying the Nazi flag in front of its governmental buildings in Dresden and said, “It’s about our heritage.”

The USA government should not butt in on this issue. Yes, the German government did, but they’re socialists.  We’re trying really hard not to be socialists, so let’s leave this as a state issue and listen to the Libertarian in me that says the US gov’t should not involve itself in this issue.

Any flag of the Confederacy represents both heritage and history.  Artifacts of history belong in a museum.  Artifacts of heritage, especially when that heritage is racist in nature, belong only in our memories.  They do not belong prominently displayed over the capitols of our states. It’s time to retire the battle flag of the Army of Northern Virginia to the museums, where we can reflect on its heritage in the context of its history.


Please leave a comment - but also please remember that this blog is read by people of all ages. Thanks!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.